Key Takeaways
Not all home improvements increase resale value.
Highly customized upgrades often fail to deliver a return on investment.
Neutral, functional updates tend to appeal to the widest range of buyers.
Overly trendy or polarizing features can reduce buyer interest.
Strategic improvements focused on usability and presentation usually perform best.
When preparing a home for sale, many homeowners assume that investing in renovations will automatically lead to a higher selling price. While certain upgrades can improve marketability, others may cost far more than they return. In some cases, well-intentioned renovations can even make a property harder to sell.
Understanding which home improvements do not add value is just as important as knowing which ones do. Buyers typically prioritize layout, functionality, condition, and overall livability over personal taste or luxury add-ons. Projects that reflect highly specific preferences often fail to resonate with the broader market.
Below are ten common home renovations that frequently fall short of expectations—along with smarter alternatives that help protect your investment and support resale value.
1. Converting a Bedroom Into a Walk-In Closet
Bedrooms play a major role in how a home is evaluated. Reducing the number of bedrooms to create a large closet may feel luxurious, but it often lowers the home’s perceived value. Many buyers search specifically by bedroom count, and losing a bedroom can significantly narrow the buyer pool.
Even if the home gains storage space, the tradeoff rarely works in favor of resale. A smaller bedroom with limited closet space is usually more valuable than fewer bedrooms with oversized storage.
What to Do Instead: Maximize Existing Closet Space
Rather than sacrificing a bedroom, focus on improving the functionality of existing closets. Built-in organizers, shelving systems, and space-saving storage solutions can dramatically improve usability without altering the home’s layout. These upgrades enhance daily living while preserving the bedroom count buyers expect.
2. Installing High-End or Custom Fixtures
Premium fixtures such as designer faucets, luxury lighting, or specialty ceiling fans can elevate a home’s appearance—but they rarely increase its appraised value. Buyers typically view fixtures as replaceable items and are unlikely to pay a premium for high-cost selections that reflect someone else’s taste.
Additionally, expensive fixtures can be perceived as unnecessary, especially if they stand out too much from the rest of the home.
What to Do Instead: Choose Durable, Mid-Range Fixtures
Opt for fixtures that are attractive, reliable, and cost-effective. Clean lines, neutral finishes, and consistent styling throughout the home create a cohesive look without overspending. Well-chosen mid-range fixtures can refresh a space while maintaining broad appeal.
3. Adding a Sunroom or Enclosed Patio
Sunrooms can be appealing to some buyers, but they are highly subjective. These additions are often costly and may not be counted as livable square footage, depending on construction standards. If the space lacks proper heating, cooling, or insulation, it may not contribute meaningfully to value.
Some buyers see sunrooms as bonus spaces, while others view them as maintenance challenges or unused square footage.
What to Do Instead: Enhance Existing Outdoor Spaces
Rather than enclosing a patio or deck, focus on improving what’s already there. Cleaning, staining, or repainting outdoor surfaces can make a significant visual impact. Adding greenery, outdoor lighting, and simple furniture helps define the space without major construction costs.
4. Using Bold or Highly Personalized Paint Colors
Statement walls, dramatic color palettes, and intricate paint designs can make a home feel expressive—but they often deter buyers. Many buyers prefer move-in-ready homes and may see bold paint as extra work or expense.
Personalized color choices can also make rooms feel smaller or less versatile.
What to Do Instead: Stick With Neutral Paint Tones
Neutral paint colors create a blank canvas that allows buyers to envision their own style. Soft whites, light grays, and warm neutrals brighten spaces and improve perceived cleanliness. Fresh paint in neutral tones is one of the most cost-effective ways to improve presentation and buyer appeal.
5. Overly Elaborate Landscaping or Outdoor Features
Curb appeal matters, but excessive landscaping rarely delivers a strong return. Features such as decorative water elements, complex stonework, or high-maintenance gardens can overwhelm buyers or raise concerns about upkeep.
Many buyers prioritize simplicity and flexibility over ornate outdoor designs.
What to Do Instead: Focus on Clean, Low-Maintenance Landscaping
Simple improvements like trimming trees, refreshing mulch, planting low-maintenance greenery, and keeping lawns tidy go a long way. Clear walkways, a welcoming entrance, and subtle lighting help create a strong first impression without unnecessary expense.
6. Trend-Driven Interior Designs
Interior trends change quickly. What feels stylish today may appear dated by the time a home hits the market. Bold wallpaper, highly specific tile patterns, or niche design styles can limit buyer interest.
Trendy features also risk clashing with a buyer’s personal taste, making the home feel less adaptable.
What to Do Instead: Embrace Timeless Design Choices
Classic finishes stand the test of time. Neutral tile, simple cabinetry, and understated decor appeal to a wider audience. Homes that feel balanced and adaptable are more likely to attract multiple offers.
7. All-White Kitchens and Bathrooms
Minimalist all-white spaces can photograph well, but they often lack warmth and practicality. These designs tend to show wear, stains, and discoloration more easily. Some buyers find them sterile or impractical for everyday living.
While popular in certain design circles, all-white interiors can be polarizing.
What to Do Instead: Add Subtle Contrast and Warmth
Small updates can dramatically improve these spaces. Repainting cabinets in soft neutrals, upgrading hardware, or replacing a central fixture can refresh the room without overwhelming it. Balanced color palettes feel more inviting and forgiving over time.
8. DIY Renovations Without Proper Permits
Do-it-yourself projects may save money upfront, but they can create issues during inspections. Work completed without permits or professional standards can raise concerns about safety, quality, and compliance.
Buyers often hesitate when faced with undocumented renovations, leading to renegotiations or delays.
What to Do Instead: Use Licensed Professionals for Major Work
For significant renovations, professional installation and proper permitting are essential. Keeping records of completed work reassures buyers and protects the home’s value. Quality workmanship reduces risk and increases buyer confidence.
9. Installing New Wall-to-Wall Carpeting
Replacing flooring with new carpet may seem like a safe choice, but many buyers prefer hard surface flooring. New carpet can feel temporary or outdated, especially if buyers plan to replace it after purchase.
In some cases, installing carpet before selling becomes an unnecessary expense.
What to Do Instead: Choose Durable, Neutral Flooring
Hard surface flooring options often appeal to a broader audience. If carpet is necessary, choose neutral tones and keep it limited to specific areas. Flooring that feels clean, durable, and versatile tends to perform better in resale scenarios.
10. Replacing Major Systems Without Necessity
Large systems like roofing or climate control equipment are essential, but replacing them solely to increase value rarely pays off. These upgrades are expensive and typically expected to be functional rather than new.
Buyers generally look for systems in good working order, not the latest model.
What to Do Instead: Address Issues Only When Needed
If a major system is failing or unsafe, repairs or replacement are necessary. Otherwise, maintaining existing systems and providing service records is usually sufficient. Functional reliability matters more than premium upgrades.
Bonus Consideration: Do Swimming Pools Increase Home Value?
Swimming pools are one of the most debated home features when it comes to resale value. Their impact varies widely based on buyer preferences, usage potential, and maintenance considerations.
Some buyers view pools as a luxury, while others see them as liabilities. Safety concerns, ongoing maintenance, and insurance costs can outweigh perceived benefits.
Building a pool is a major investment with no guaranteed return. If resale value is the primary goal, funds are often better allocated toward universally appealing improvements.
Final Thoughts
When preparing a home for sale, the goal is not to impress with extravagance, but to appeal to the widest possible audience. Functional layouts, neutral finishes, and well-maintained systems consistently outperform highly personalized or trend-driven renovations.
Before starting any project, consider how it will be perceived by someone seeing the home for the first time. Improvements that make a home feel clean, flexible, and move-in ready are far more likely to support a successful sale than costly upgrades driven by personal taste.
By avoiding renovations that don’t add value—and choosing smarter alternatives—you protect your investment and position your home for a smoother, more profitable sale.
King & Edge Real Estate Agents in Boise, Idaho
As experienced Boise real estate agents, we are honored to have the opportunity to serve you and be a part of your real estate journey. Let us guide you towards a successful and rewarding experience, where your goals become our goals, and your vision becomes a reality. Contact us today and discover the unparalleled service and expertise that sets King & Edge Real Estate apart as we help you sell your home in Boise or find your place to call home.
// View Our Portfolio of Listings
Stacey King Boise Real Estate Agent
Raised in a family engaged in custom building and real estate appraisal, Stacey was destined for a career in real estate. Moving to Boise in 2010, she developed a deep love for the area, purchasing her first home in 2016, a step that ignited her passion to help others experience the transformative power of homeownership. Stacey has built her business on integrity, exceptional client experience, meaningful relationships, and community investment. She dedicates a portion of each commission to support local and global charities, with a special passion for the Women’s and Children’s Alliance, aiding victims of domestic abuse. Stacey’s commitment to her clients and her community has paved the way for enduring friendships and a fulfilling career.
